
You could be celebrating like Mike if your leaguemates decide to pass on Cuddyer.
It is likely that Michael Cuddyer will not be a very highly coveted fantasy outfielder in 2010 because of some uncertainties moving foward. Many will view Cuddy’s robust 09 as having the “Ludwick Look” and will forecast huge regression for the upcoming season. I am not going to bet the farm on Cuddyer repeating his career best season, but I will however tell you that there is plenty of value to be had here.
First off, Cuddyer was only 1 of 7 outfielders to surpass 30 bombs and both 90 runs scored and 90 runs batted in a year ago. The elite company who share that (Braun, Lind, Bay, Werth, Ethier, Ibanez) should have him sniffing #2 outfield status. I do not believe in drafting Cuddyer like a #2, but view him as more than solid number 3.
Haters will say:
Cuddyer will struggle in his new digs as it is outside and he loved his home cooking at the Metrodome where he slugged .555 with 18 bombs a season ago.
I will say:
No one has any clue how a new ballpark is going to play, but I will say that it is likely the new Target Field can be no worse for hitters than the Metrodome has been over the last few seasons. It has been falsely nicknamed the Homerdome in years past and has actually favored the pitchers historically. The fence in left is actually 16 feet closer to home plate at Target than it was at the old Metrodome. This should play nicely for the pull happy Cuddyer.
Haters will say:
Cuddyer’s 09 was out of left field and has to be the outlier in his last 4 seasons. His homerun/flyball rate spiked along with his fly ball rate and is the main reason for his explosion. It cannot be repeated.
I will say:
Cuddyer had a solid 2006 season when he hit 24 homers and drove in 109. He was being viewed as an up and comer before disappointing the following year with a modest 16 and 81 before bottoming out in 2008, slugging .370 in 249 at bats. On the surface, it seemed Michael was on a downward spiral. Looking closer, 2007 was a bump in the road and 2008 was an anomoly when you consider he battled several injuries throughout the abbreviated season.
Haters will say:
But seriously, you cannot be talking me into Michael Cuddyer.
I will conclude by saying:
Michael Cuddyer is currently being drafting about 100 picks after LA boy Andre Ethier. Ethier should be the more targeted outfielder, but looking at their 2009 season the gap shouldn’t be nearly that large. They were categorically the same player a season ago (Cuddyer actually hit more homers and scored more runs). Cuddyer is sandwiched in a superb lineup between Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau, and Jason Kubel. I envision Gardy keeping Cuddy in the 5 spot the entire season to break up the portsiders. I love Ethier this season but cannot ignore the fact that he couldn’t hit his ass against lefties and plays in a pitcher’s paradise (even though he killed it at Chavez last year). On the flip side, Cuddyer had an OPS of 1.014 against lefties and will chip in a handful of steals to go with his strong counting numbers. Ethier is never going to be a plus in batting average until he solves the quagmire of the left-handed pitcher. Cuddyer’s BA won’t hurt you.
Stick to your guns and NEVER pay for the career year. But when your leaguemates view Cuddyer as an afterthought because his 2009 came seemingly out of nowhere, pounce on Cuddyer in round 12 or for around 10 bones in your auction. He will keep it Midwest, grab his hardhat, and punch the clock for your fantasy squad.
The Final Line Will Say: .274-26 HR-94 RBI-5 SB-86 R